Comparison of Clinical and Histopathological Behavior of Oral Leukoplakia Before and After Treatment with 1% Topical Clotrimazole - An Observational Study
Citation: Vizhi K. Comparison of Clinical and Histopathological Behavior of Oral Leukoplakia Before and After Treatment With 1% Topical Clotrimazole- An Observational Study. J Basic Clin Pharma 2017;8:226-229.
This open-access article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (CC BY-NC) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits reuse, distribution and reproduction of the article, provided that the original work is properly cited and the reuse is restricted to noncommercial purposes. For commercial reuse, contact [email protected]inpharm.org
Background: The Etiological role of Candida albicans in malignant transformation of oral leukoplakia is much debated in the recent times.
Aim and objectives: To compare the clinical and histopathological behavior of oral leukoplakia before and after antifungal therapy with 1% topical clotrimazole. To assess the candida colony count in saliva and correlation between salivary candidal colonies count in patients with oral leukoplakia before and after treatment with antifungal 1% topical clotrimazole therapy.
Methods: Clinical behavior of 50 cases of oral leukoplakia was assessed and histopathological confirmed as not any other lesion. Unstimulated whole saliva sample collection for estimating candida colony count and exfoliative cytology of the lesion were performed with cytobrush to evaluate candidal hyphae and other histopathological changes using PAS and Hematoxylin-Eosin stains. Subjects were prescribed 1% topical clotrimazole thrice daily for two weeks and were recalled after two weeks and the same procedures were repeated sequentially. Paired t test was used for Statistical analysis setting the p value at <0.001.
Results: Statistically significant difference was observed in the clinical staging, histopathological behavior and the salivary candida colony counts before and after treatment with 1% topical clotrimazole. Conclusion: Significant influence of Candida in the Clinico-pathological behavior of leukoplakia merits treatment with topical antifungals like 1%clotrimazole
Antifungal therapy, candida colony count, clotrimazole, oral leukoplakia
Oral Leukoplakia (OL) is the most common Potentially Malignant Disorder of the oral mucosa with a reported malignant transformation rate of 1.36%.[1,2] Candida invasion has been suggested to be a significant risk factor for malignant transformation of OL. Literature search showed that candidal hyphae constitute 7-50% of all Leukoplakia.[4,5] Though the role of candida on epithelial dysplasia is not fully understood, antifungal therapy is recommended to be a routine treatment for OL. Due to paucity of direct studies our research was carried out with an aim to correlate the clinical staging and histopathological behavior of leukoplakia with salivary candida colony count before and after treatment with topical antifungal therapy.
Materials and Methods
The observational study was conducted at a Dental hospital after obtaining clearance from Institutional Review Board and Ethical Committee. Fifty subjects with clinical diagnosis of OL were included in the study after obtaining informed consent. Patients with chronic systemic illness, oral cancer, corticosteroid therapy, immunosuppressive drugs, allergic to clotrimazole, pregnancy, primary and acquired immunodeficiency were excluded from the study.
Cases were selected based on OL (OLEP) staging system proposed by Van der Waal and Axéll et al. [Table 1] and the information was entered in a specially designed proforma. Incisional biopsy was then performed for histopathological confirmation of the lesion. Following clinico pathologic correlation, subjects were asked to pool saliva in their mouth and the unstimulated whole saliva was collected in a sterile container. The samples were inoculated in Sabouraud’s dextrose agar media at 37°C for 48 hours. Candida Colony Forming Units (CFU) was counted using the colony counter by the microbiologists at the department of Microbiology who were completely blind about the clinical staging of the lesion.
|L1||Size of single or multiple leukoplakia together ≤ 2 cm|
|L3||Size of single or multiple leukoplakia together ≥ 4 cm|
|Lx||Size not specified|
|No epithelial dysplasia (includes “no or perhaps mild epithelial dysplasia'')|
|P1||Distinct epithelial dysplasia (includes “mild to moderate'' and ``moderate to possibly severe'' epithelial dysplasia)|
|Px||Absence or presence of epithelial dysplasia not specified in the pathology report|
|OLEP staging system:
|Stage III||L3P0 or L1L2P1|
Table 1: Classification and Staging system for Oral Leukoplakia (OLEP) -Vander Wall (2002)
Exfoliative cytology of the lesion using cytobrush was performed to identify the presence of Candidal hyphae and other histopathological changes using PAS and Hematoxylin-Eosin (HE) stains respectively. Sitheeque suggested that histologically, Candida invasion was best done by periodic acid-Schiff (PAS) reagent staining. Subjects were counseled for habit cessation and advised to apply topical 1% clotrimazole on the lesion thrice daily for two weeks.
Method of application was explained and medication compliance charts printed in the local language with easily understandable tabular columns were given to the subjects to assess adherence to the regimen. The subjects were recalled after two weeks and assessed for clinical staging based on size, excluding the pathological aspects as per Van der Waal’s Modified staging system [c-OLEP- Table 2] and saliva sample was collected to estimate the Candida colony count. Exfoliative cytology of the lesion was repeated using cytobrush to identify Candidal hyphae and other histopathological changes using PAS and Hematoxylin-Eosin (HE) stains respectively. The obtained data was tabulated and subjected to statistical analysis using SPSS software version 20. Paired t test was used to compare the clinical staging and salivary colony counts before and after treatment. Chi square test was done to compare the presence of candida hyphae, setting p value at <0.001.
|Stage III||L3C1 or L1L2C2|
Table 2: Van der Waal-a modified classification and staging system for oral leukoplakia: c-OLEP system
There was no attrition of subjects and medication compliance was found adequate with all the subjects following the instructions. The age distribution ranged from 20-70 years, with a mean age of 50.14 ± 10.76 years. Peak occurrence of OL was observed between ages 51-60 years with a male predilection i.e. 94%, compared to 6% of females. The entire study group had deleterious oral habits. Of which 32 patients (64%) had smoking habits, 18 cases (36%) had smokeless tobacco (chewing) habit, and 28 cases (56%) had the habit of using both smoking and smokeless tobacco. Site predilection was highest with buccal mucosa constituting 90% of the cases followed by labial mucosa and vestibular region 4% each and 2% of cases in the retro molar region.
Among the study group (n 50) 43 cases (86%) quit their habits completely in the post-operative visit and 7 cases could not stop the habit completely. Histopathological grading showed 40% of leukoplakia cases with mild dysplasia, 2% cases with moderate dysplasia and 58% without any dysplastic features. Among the types of Leukoplakia, 39 cases (78%) were homogenous and 11 cases (22%) were non homogenous. Out of 39 homogenous leukoplakia patients candidal hyphae were observed in 11 cases and in 11 cases of non-homogenous patients showed candidal hypae in 10 cases. There was complete elimination of candidal hyphae in cytosmear in all the 50 cases following treatment. Chi square test showed a statistically significant p value of <0.00.
Salivary Candidal colony count ranged between 0-8000 CFU/ml, out of which only 1 case (2%) was in the normal limits of 0-600 CFU/ml. The rest of the 49 cases (98%) had a count of 800-8000 CFU/ml before treatment. Following treatment,35 cases (70%) showed Candidal count at normal limits of 0-600 CFU/ml and 17 cases (30%) showed reduction of Candidal counts to 0-2000 CFU/ml. Paired t test showed statistically significant reduction in CFU with a p value of < 0.001. The pre and post treatment CFU counts are as shown in Table 3.
|Colony count||No of Cases in pre treatment||No of cases in post treatment|
Table 3: Candida colony counts before and after treatment
OL is regarded as a premalignant or, synonymously a potentially malignant or precancerous lesion. Candida albicans is the most prevalent fungus associated with about 7-50% of oral leukoplakias.[8,9] Candida invasion has been suggested to be a significant risk factor for malignant transformation of oral leukoplakia.
By definition, there is no clear correlation between clinical and pathologic diagnosis of Leukoplakia as clinically similar lesions may be histologically different. Therefore, biopsy should be performed in all cases to determine potential malignancy.A staging system for OL (OLEP) combining the clinical aspects and histopathological findings has been proposed by Van der Waal. If the staging system should be used for studies in which no biopsies are available (in our study, follow up biopsy was not recommended due to ethical issues) one could use a symbol for the clinical (C) subdivision of OLEP staging (C1=homogeneous; C2=non-homogeneous) instead of the one for pathology. With reference to the original classification and staging system (Van der Waal), this would result in a c-OLEP system, recognizing four stages.
Among the types of Leukoplakia, the homogenous type is more prevalent than the non-homogenous type [Table 2]. Our study showed similar findings constituting of 78% of cases of homogenous leukoplakia compared to 22% of non-homogenous leukoplakia.
Among the 50 cases included as per the defined inclusion criteria, the present study showed male predilection of 94% (Male: Female ratio of 15.2:1) with peak occurrence observed between the age group of 51-60 years which is consistent with the study done by Banoczy.
Jepsen and Winther found a strong association between candidal invasion and speckled leukoplakia which was later confirmed in many studies. Vander waal recommended 2-4 weeks of antifungal therapy for non-homogenous leukoplakia to observe improvement in the lesion. Vander waal also stated that 2-4 week interval to observe the possible regression or disappearance of a white lesion after elimination of possible causative factors, seems an acceptable period of time.
Observing for the presence of candidal hyphae in cytosmear before and after treatment and correlating the candida colonization with the salivary candida counts, 42% of cases showed presence of candidal hyphae before treatment and absence of candidal hyphae in all the cases following topical application of 1% clotrimazole for 2 weeks. (D1) Nada Vuckovic suggested that leukoplakias associated with conventional forms of smoking showed candidal hyphae more often than those associated with tobacco chewing. It is generally believed that the presence of candidal hyphae merely represents a superimposed infection. Candidal colonization of Leukoplakia is believed to be higher in smokers of tobacco than chewers of tobacco as smoking induces higher degree of epithelial keratinization favoring candidal colonization. Reduction in levels of Salivary IgA and depression of polymorph nuclear leukocyte function also favor increased candidal colonization in smokers. Our study found that 64% of the subjects used Smoked tobacco which could be the reason for the high percentage of candidal hyphae observed before treatment.
Assimilating the observed results, 48% of cases showed improvement in staging i.e. got reversed to L1P0 stage; 12%cases got reversed to L2P0 from a higher stage and 40% of cases remained at L1P0 stage following treatment. Though there was post treatment reduction in the size of the clinical lesion in those 40% of cases (L1P0), there was no difference observed in staging following treatment. The regression in size of the lesion could not be documented in the form of staging because a lesion < 2 cm however small, has to be graded as L1. Hence a pretreatment lesion which is 2 cm in size regressing to 0.5 cm post treatment still is graded as L1 [Table 4].
|Staging before treatment||No of cases||Staging after treatment||No of cases|
|L3P0 or L1L2P1||16||L3P0||0|
Table 4: Comparison of pre and post treatment clinical staging
Warnakulasuriya found that Non homogeneous lesions carry a much higher risk of malignant transformation. In our study 14% cases of non-homogenous leukoplakia into homogenous leukoplakia following treatment. Most interesting observation in our study was the significant reduction in the size of the lesion and improvement in the clinical staging of leukoplakia before and after topical antifungal therapy thus reducing the changes of malignant transformation (D2). We also observed a significant reduction in candida colony count following the application of 1% w/v clotrimazole which directly correlated to clinical staging and candida colonization of the lesion which strongly signifies the role of Candida in Leukoplakia (D3).
Though candidal infection in leukoplakic lesions are mostly considered as a local association, the higher salivary colony counts estimated in most of the leukoplakia cases in our study provide a strong evidence of correlation of salivary candida level to tissue colonization.
The significant regression of the lesions and clinical presentation of the lesions also can be attributed partly to the Habit counseling performed before treatment. Even then, 48% of the cases improving to L1P0 stage along with reduction in Salivary Candidal count and complete elimination of candida hyphae emphasize the role of topical Clotrimazole antifungal therapy.
Maghu et al. have stated that a complete elimination of fungal hyphae could be achieved only by clotrimazole. Clotrimazole proved to be 100% successful in the reduction of clinical and histopathological features. An important observation was the reduction in the Salivary Candidal count and complete absence of Candida Hyphae after treatment with antifungal agent. Paired t test showed significant reduction in CFU with a p value of < 0.001. The reduction in the candida colony count before and after application of antifungal therapy conforms with study results of Pragati et al. In a study conducted by Cao, OL cases found significant correlation with saliva culture results and concluded that candidal infection may be one of the most important factors inducing dysplasia of epithelia and malignant transformation of oral leukoplakia thus emphasizing salivary candida culture as a routine procedure for patients with OL.
Strength of the Study
Evaluation of the association of candidal hyphae in cytosmear as well as estimation of candidal colony count in saliva simultaneously before and after treatment with topical antifungal therapy has added up to the strength of the study. The present study showed 11 cases of nonhomogenous leukoplakia, in which 7 cases turned into homogenous leukoplakia post treatment with application of 1% w/v clotrimazole antifungal therapy. There is a significant change in clinical staging of leukoplakia cases which strongly signifies the role of Candida in Leukoplakia.
Conversion of a Non-homogenous Leukoplakia to a Homogenous Leukoplakia thus reduces the potential for malignancy.
Topical Clotrimazole proves to be an economical, easily available, patient compliant and effective antifungal therapy necessarily recommended in management of Leukoplakia.
Limitations of the Study
Inclusion of more number of cases with different histopathological grading might result in more conclusive result of candidal association and the prognosis of pre malignant lesion, leukoplakia cases.
There are conflicting opinions regarding the presence and association of candida with malignant and premalignant lesions. Few authors believe candida does not prove to have a causal relationship and its presence in Leukoplakia is incidental and is only a colonizer of a preexisting lesion under favorable environmental conditions. Others say candida may have a direct or indirect role in the carcinogenesis and specifically some Candida albicans biotypes might contribute more too oral carcinogenesis than others. Though the association of Candida albicans in the malignant transformation of potentially malignant lesions is not proven with strong evidences, the present study assessing the clinical staging of oral leukoplakia, presence of candidal hyphae in the lesion and salivary candidal colony count before and after treatment with antifungal therapy showed improvement in the clinical staging, elimination of the candida hyphae and significant reduction in the salivary colony counts in the lesions. High candida colony counts in saliva before treatment also suggests the possible correlation of candida with the clinical stage of leukoplakia. The possible role of Candida in progression of leukoplakia is evident from the significant reduction of the candidal colony count and improvement in the clinical staging after the application of 1% w/v clotrimazole, Based on our results, a conclusion can be drawn that topical application of 1% w/v clotrimazole antifungal agent on Oral Leukoplakia significantly reduces the candidal colony count in saliva as well as the candidal hyphe associated with the lesion and therefore results in improvement in clinical staging and arrest progression of the lesions.
Conflict of Interest
External funding source
- Warnakulasuriya S, Newell, Johnson W, Van der WI. Nomenclature and classification of potentially malignant disorders of the oral mucosa. J Oral Pathol Med 2007;36:575-801.
- Van der WI, Axell T. Oral Leukoplakia: a proposal for uniform reporting. Oral Oncology 2002;38:521-6.
- Wei Liu, Yu-Feng W, Hai-Wei Zhou, Peng Shi, Zeng-Tong Zhou, Guo-Yao Tang. Malignant transformation of oral leukoplakia: a retrospective cohort study of 218 Chinese patients. BMC Cancer 2010;10:685.
- Van der WI, SchepmanKP, Van der MEH. A modified classification and staging system for oral Leukoplakia. Oral Oncology 2000;36:264-6.
- Sanjaya PR, Gokul S, Guru raj Patil B, Ramanjeneya Raju. Candida in oral pre-cancer and oral cancer .Medical Hypotheses 2011;77:1125-8.
- Vuèkovia N, Bokor-Bratic M, Vuekovic D, Picuric I. Presence of Candida albicans in potentially malignant oral mucosal lesions. Arch Oncol 2004;12:51-4.
- Sitheeque MA, Samaranayake LP. Chronic hyperplastic candidosis/candidiasis (candidal leukoplakia). Crit Rev Oral Biol Med 2003;14:253-67.
- Vázquez-Álvarez R, Fernández-González F, Gándara-Vila P, Reboiras-López D, Abel García-García, José-Manuel Gándara-Rey. Correlation between clinical and pathologic correlation in oral Leukoplakia in 54 patients. Med Oral Patol Oral Cir Bucal 2010;15:e832-8.
- Mohammed H, Abdulrahim BA, McManus SR. Flint DC, Coleman. Genotyping Candida albicans from Candida Leukoplakia and Non-Candida Leukoplakia Shows No Enrichment of Multilocus Sequence Typing Clades but Enrichment of ABC Genotype C in Candida Leukoplakia. Plos One 2013;8:e73738.
- Sdubba JJ. Oral leukoplakia. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med 1995;6:147-60.
- Elisabeth-REA B, Jacques-AB, Elisabeth B, Hakki K, Isaäc van der W. The relevance of uniform reporting in oral leukoplakia: Definition, certainty factor and staging based on experience with 275 patients. Med Oral Pathol OralCir Bucal 2013;18:19-26.
- Van der Waal I, Schepman KP, Van der Meij EH, Smeele LE. Oral Leukoplakia: a Clinicopathological Review. Oral Oncology 1997;33:291-301.
- Bánóczy J, Gintner Z, Dombi C. Tobacco use and oral leukoplakia. J Dent Educ 2001;65:322-7.
- Maghu S, Desai VD, Sharma R. Comparison of efficacy of alternative medicine with allopathy in treatment of oral fungal infection. Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine.2015;1-4.
- Hebbar PB, Anuradha P, Sujatha D. Mycological and histological associations of Candida in oral mucosal lesions. Journal of Oral Science 2013;55:157-60.
- Cao J, Liu HW, Jin JQ. The effect of oral candida to development of oral leukoplakia into cancer. Chinese Journal of Preventive Medicine 2007;41:90-93.