Medication Counseling Practice in Ethiopia, a Systematic Review
- *Corresponding Author:
- Mohammed Ayalew
Department of Clinical Pharmacy, School of Pharmacy, College of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Gondar, Gondar, Ethiopia.
E-mail: [email protected]
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as the author is credited and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
Background: Patient counselling is one of the most important services conducted by drug dispensers. The aim of this review was to derive results from various studies conducted on medication counselling in Ethiopia and make an overall view about medication counselling activities, types of information provided during counselling, conditions given special attention during counselling and barriers to counselling in Ethiopia. Methods: Relevant literatures related to medication counselling practice in Ethiopia were obtained from Pub Med and Google Scholar databases and manual Google search. Some articles were also obtained by searching the reference lists of retrieved articles. Systemic analysis was made on 6 articles and the results were summarized. Results: Five of the articles reviewed were conducted by using self-administered questionnaire while one was done through face to face interview and observation. Dose, frequency and route of administration of the drug were very frequently (>90%) delivered to the patient while the name and the purpose of the medication was less frequently told. special attention was given by majority of the dispensers to pregnant women (86.8%)and patients with hypertension (78.2%). Lack of knowledge and updated drug information (61.3%) and presence of high patient load (45.3%) were the most frequently mentioned barriers for counselling. Conclusion: Even though there are many things to be told to the patient/client while dispensing a medication the counselling activities conducted in Ethiopia were not far more than telling when and how much to take. Lack of knowledge and presence of high patient load were the commonly mentioned obstacles for providing appropriate counselling.
Medication counseling, drug dispensing, counseling practice, pharmacy, Ethiopia
Patient counselling is one of the most important services provided by drug dispensers. counselling is defined by some authors as advicegiving or provision of information on medications.[1-3] Nevertheless, Rees argues that what pharmacists give is much more than just advice because this process involves empathic understanding, acceptance, and genuine feelings from pharmacists. Other researchers have focused more on the goal of counselling, that is ensuring patients understanding of the optimal use of medications to improve their quality of life.[2,5,6] The Ethiopian manual for medicines good dispensing practice also states that in supplying medicines, pharmacists must ensure that ‘‘the patient receives sufficient information and advice to enable the safe and effective use of medicines.’’
In achieving optimal use of medications, patients should be informed about how to use their medications properly. Therefore, counselling should include information such as name and purpose of the medication, directions for use, side effects, precautions, contraindications, and storage as well as monitoring for drug interactions and adverse drug reactions.[6,8] several guidelines that have been published by professional organizations in the USA and Australia also emphasize that the pharmacist’s professional judgment is needed to meet the specific needs of each patient and/or caregiver.[9-13]
Through patient counselling, pharmacists may identify and resolve drug-related problems, empower patients to adopt positive selfmanagement behaviour, increase patient satisfaction with pharmacy care and optimize patient quality of care.[14-18] It is the pharmacists’ role to significantly improve medication safety and patient compliance by the way of counselling at the point of delivery. Counselling not only enhances compliance but also reduces complications due to non-compliance to treatment. Assessment should also be handled whether or not the information was received as intended and that the patient understands how to use the information to improve the probability of therapeutic out comes.
Dispensing with appropriate counselling is a critical part of drug use process. Worldwide more than 50% of all medicines are prescribed, dispensed or sold inappropriately.[21,22] Inappropriate use of drugs can lead to wastage of resources and also causes significant patient harm in terms of poor patient outcomes and adverse drug reactions.[21-23]
Although providing patients with adequate and clear information on drugs is one of the basic services expected to be rendered by the pharmacist, it seems that it has received little attention in Ethiopia. It is presumed that shortage of qualified personnel, lack of preparedness of the practicing pharmacist, and community perception towards practicing pharmacist have significantly contributed to the existing several problems in the practice of pharmacy in general and patient counselling in particular.[24,25] Previous reviews of research regarding drug dispensers’ counselling practice have primarily focused on an international perspective or at developed nation and there is no review article done on the topic in Ethiopia. So the aim of this review was to derive results from various studies conducted on medication counselling in Ethiopia and make an overall view about medication counselling practice in Ethiopia.
Relevant articles related to medication counselling practice in Ethiopia were searched from Pub-med and Google Scholar databases. Manual Google search was also used to get articles published in journals which were not indexed in these databases. The search was done using the keywords ‘medication counselling in Ethiopia’, ‘practice of medication counseling among drug dispensers in Ethiopia’, ‘drug dispensing in Ethiopia’. The reference lists of all retrieved articles were also cheeked for presence of relevant article to this review and manually searched on the internet. The review was restricted to Ethiopia and articles that were published in English language in the last 10 years were collected. All of the articles found in the search results were considered for this review irrespective of the study method, the type of medications assessed (prescription or non-prescription medication) and pharmacy type (community pharmacy or hospital pharmacy). A total of 187 articles were obtained, out of which only 13 articles were identified to be showing relevance to the study. Abstract-only articles were filtered from 13 articles. Articles were reviewed if they were original research. Studies exploring consumer satisfaction with pharmacist counselling and those focusing on practice of written communication (labelling) were excluded. Finally 6 articles were included for this study. Study year, area, research methods, sample size, participant’s characteristics, counselling activities, information given for the patient/client, conditions given special attention and barriers to counselling were extracted. Analysis was made on these articles and the results were summarized.
All of the studies reviewed were cross-sectional studies that assessed the practice of medication counseling as one component of knowledge, attitude and practice of medication counseling among drug dispensers or as an exclusive assessment for practice of medication counseling in governmental and private drug retail outlets. Five of these studies were conducted by giving self-administered questionnaire to 48-64 drug dispensers while one of the studies was conducted through interviewer administered questionnaire to 30 dispensers and observation cheek list for 400 dispensing encounters. As shown in Table 1, in all of the studies male study subjects were predominant (more than one third of study subjects). Majority of the dispensers were druggists (diploma holders). Pharmacists were only 22.7% (range=6.25%-40%) of all the dispensers. In some areas non pharmacy professionals like nurses and health assistants were involved in drug dispensing.
year of publication
|Nasir et al. 2011||Mohammed etal. 2015||Wubante, 2014||Abebawet al. 2014||Alefeet al. 2014||Desalegnet al.2015||Total|
|Study area||North West Ethiopia||South West? Ethiopia||Bahir Dar||Awi Zone,||Jimma||Gondar||-|
|Study method||Crossectional||Crossectional||cross sectional
|cross sectional||cross sectional||cross sectional||-|
|Sample population||Total sample size||64||50||30 (400 dispensing encounters)||48||49||63||304|
|Male||35 (54.7%)||42(84%)||20 (66.7%)||37 (77.1%)||34 (69.4%)||42 (66.7%)||210(69.1%)|
|Female||29(45.3%)||8(16%)||10 (33.3%)||11 (22.9%)||15 (30.6%)||21 (33.3%)||94(30.9%)|
|Working sector||Private||56(87.5%)||31(62%)||12 (40%)||37 (77.1%)||37 (75.5%)||NR||173(71.8%)|
|governmental||8(12.5%)||19(38%)||18 (60%)||11 (22.9%)||12 (24.5%)||NR||68(28.2%)|
|qualification||Pharmacist||12 (18.8%)||10(20%)||12 (40%)||3 (6.25%)||10 (20.4%)||22 (34.9)||69(22.7%)|
|Drugist||43(67.2%)||32(64%)||18 (60%)||25 (52.1%)||35 (71.4%)||41 (65.1%)||194(63.8%)|
|Pharmacy technician||3(4.7%)||4(8%)||0 (0%)||16 (33.33%)||4 (8.2%)||0(0%)||27(8.9%)|
|Others*||6(9.4%)||4(8%)||0 (0%)||4 (8.3%)||0 (0%)||0(0%)||14(4.6%)|
NR Not Reported; *health assistant and nurses
Table 1: Characteristics of studies conducted to address medication counseling practice in Ethiopia
Results obtained about counselling activities were inconsistent throughout the studies. Overall the counselling activities performed were not satisfactory. As shown in Table 2, the study conducted in south west Ethiopia (Agaro, Limmu Genet and Sokuru towns) reported better counselling activities than studies conducted in the other part of the country. Lesser medication counselling was given regarding what to do if a patient misses a dose (43.1%) and about major side effects of a drug (48.0%).
|Study area||North West Ethiopia||South West? Ethiopia||Bahir Dar||Awi Zone,||Jimma||Gondar||Average|
|Author, year of publication||Nasir et al. 2011||Mohammed etal. 2015||Wubante, 2014||Abebawet al. 2014||Alefeet al. 2014||Desalegnet al.2015|
|Counselling activities||Tell purpose of each counselling||9(14.1%)||43 (86%)||39 (79.6%)||59.9%|
|Ask patients what prescriber has told||11(17.2%)||45(90%)||36 (73.5%)||60.2%|
|Ask patients if they have problems in taking the drug(s) as prescribed||15(23.4%)||47(94%)||34 (69.4%)||62.3%|
|Discus major side effects||12(18.8%)||48(96%)||29(15.1%)||26 (53.1%)||36 (57.1)||48.0%|
|Discus life-style modifications||49(76.6%)||45(90)||32 (65.3%)||34 (53.9)||71.5%|
|Tell what to do if a patient misses a dose||5(7.8%)||33(66%)||15(31.3%)||33 (67.4%)||43.1%|
|Open the container and show what the drug look like||33(51.6%)||47 (94%)||28 (57.1%)||67.6%|
|Check patient understanding by asking to repeat back key information||46(71.8%)||47 (94%)||202(50.5%)||32 (77.6%)||22(34.9%)||65.8%|
Table 2: Counselling activities conducting during drug dispensing in Ethiopia.
Type of information given to the patient
Assessment regarding the information given for the patient was done in some of the studies through how often (always, often, sometimes, rarely or never) the dispensers practice each of the parameters or by ticking weather they practice each of the parameters as yes or no option in some other studies. As indicated in Table 3, frequency of administration of a drug (97.5%), its route of administration (97%) and its dose (90.3%) were almost always told to the patient during drug dispensing. Telling the name and the purpose of the medication is the very less frequently delivered information to the patient while dispensing the drug.
|Author, year of publication||Nasir et al. 2011||Mohammed et al. 2015||Wubante, 2014||Abebawet al.2014||Alefeet al. 2014||Average*|
|Percentage of respondents||%||%||%||%||%||%|
|Information given for the patient||Tell name of the drug||Always||0||44||NA||12.5||44.9||29.6|
|Tell route of administration||Always||96.9||94||NA||75.0||100||97|
|Tell dose of drug||Always||100||77||99.2||100||93.8||90.3|
|Tell frequency of administration||Always||98.4||94||96||100||100||97.5|
|Tell why the drug is prescribed||Always||4.7||36||NA||NA||46.9||29.2|
|Tell duration of therapy||Always||9.4||86||74||NA||89.8||61.7|
|Tell interactions||Always||28.1||60||DDI=35.5||13 27.1||73.5||53.9|
|Tell storage condition||Always||0||50||4.5%||56.3||71.4||40.5|
Table 3: Types of Information given to the patient during medication counselling in Ethiopia.
Conditions given special attention
As shown in Table 4, majority of dispensers give special attention to pregnant women (86.8%) and patients with hypertension (78.2%). From conditions that need special attention during counselling relatively lesser emphasis was given for special drug conditions (40.7%- 64.8%) than special patient and disease conditions (54.7%-86.8%).
|Author, Year of publication||Nasir et al. 2011||Mohammed etal. 2015||Abebawet al.2014||Alefeet al.2014||Average|
|Percentage of respondents||%||%||%||%||%|
|special patient conditions||Pregnancy||82.8%||96%||68.8%||100%||86.8|
|Taking multiple medicine||56.2%||70%||45.8%||75.5%||61.9|
|Special disease conditions||Asthma||43.8%||60%||39.6%||75.5%||54.7|
|special drug conditions||Under active surveillance by FMHACA||34.4%||NA||NA||46.9%||40.7|
|With significant side effect||59.0%||57.1%||58.1|
|With additional warning||43.8%||69.3%||56.6|
|With complicated direction||62.5%||65.3%||63.7|
|With special storage condition||50%||79.6%||64.8|
NA Not Assessed
Table 4: Conditions given special attention during medication counselling in Ethiopia
Barriers to counselling
Table 5 indicates that lack of knowledge and updated drug information (61.3%) and presence of high patient load (45.3%) were the most frequently mentioned barriers for counselling.
|Author, year of publication||Nasir et al. 2011||Mohammed etal. 2015||Abebawet al. 2014||Alefeet al. 2014||Desalegnet al.2015||Average|
|Barriers to counselling||Lack of knowledge and updated drug information||28(43.8%)||28(56%)||29(60.4%)||32(65.3%)||51(80.9%)||61.3%|
|High patient load||19(29.7%)||37(74%)||17(35.4%)||39(79.6%)||5(7.9%)||45.3%|
|Non legalization of counselling||16(25%)||6(12%)||NA||4 (8.2%)||NA||15.1%|
|Patient factors||12(18.8%)||20(40%)||5 (10.4%)||31(63.3%)||NA||33.1%|
|No factor||3(4.7%)||NA||0 (0%)||0 (0%)||0 (0%)||1.2%|
NA Not Assessed
Table 5: Barriers for medication counselling in Ethiopia.
Greater emphasis must be placed on medication counselling in order to improve the patient outcome after treatment and reduce the occurrence of medication related errors. The link between the medication and the patient is through the pharmacist. So any relevant information about the drug to the patient is expected to be delivered from the pharmacist during counselling. A number of studies also reported that pharmacists should provide relevant, understandable and appropriate information to patients about their medication.[25-27] even though providing patients with clear and adequate information on their medication is the basic services expected to be given by the pharmacist; it seems that it has given less attention in Ethiopia.
Drug consumers expressed that their awareness of the importance of taking their medications increased if they receive information about their medications. According to Berhane et al. patients rated all aspects of drug information about their treatment were relevant.
Dickinson et al. also stated that patients may want to know more than we think of them. However according to this review some aspects of counselling activities performed were not adequate. For example telling the name and the purpose of the drug is the information which is less frequently delivered to the patient during dispensing of the drug. However the need for the indication of a drug was cited as most patients want to know.
Even though all the necessary information expected to be delivered during drug dispensing were not delivered the dose of the drug, frequency and route of administration were almost always told to the patient during drug dispensing. Similarly the study done in Saudi Arabia reported that information regarding dose was the most common type of information provided by pharmacists. An observational study done in Pakistan also mentioned that dose and frequency of the medicines were more commonly communicated to patients than any other information during drug dispensing. A review article done by Hanni et al. states that information on dose and directions for use was more frequently given than information on side effects, precautions, interactions, contraindications, and storage.
Studies have shown that people want to be told about the possibility of any adverse effects they might suffer as a result of taking medicines. [34-36] Berry et al. described between 50 and 90% of patients express a desire for more information about adverse effects. However discussing on major side effects was a very less frequently performed counselling activity reported in this review. Some pharmacists believed that information on side effects may frighten some consumers so that they may stop taking their medications.
In all of the studies reviewed the most frequently mentioned barriers for counselling were lack of knowledge and updated drug information and presence of high patient load. Similarly the study conducted in Lagos State South West Nigeria reported that workload in the pharmacy followed by lack of appropriate drug information sources were rated high as barriers to medication counselling. Workload is also reported as a frequently mentioned factor influencing practitioner-patient relationship in many other studies.[40-44] There are also many studies that indicate lack of knowledge is the major barrier to counselling.[45,46] The need for practical training on medication counselling is an important issue that should be considered by authorities who are concerned for the basic and continuing education of pharmacists. Concerned officials should also increase the human power involved in drug dispensing in order to make pharmacy professionals get time for counselling.
Even though the maximum possible published studies that address medication counseling practice in Ethiopia were found through Google scholar and Pub-med databases as well as manual Google search, the total number of studies obtained may not be sufficient to get the overall image of the country regarding medication counseling practice. Publication bias could also be a limitation since I did not get unpublished papers to include in this review. The quality of individual studies is also a concern because almost all of the studies were crosssectional studies whose data were obtained through the report of the professionals not a simulated visit or an observation. This is because studies have reported inconsistencies between self-reported behaviour of pharmacists in interviews and their actual dispensing practice measured using Simulated Patients.
This review highlights the current deficiencies of medication counselling practice in Ethiopia. Even though there are many things to be told to the patient while dispensing a medication the counselling activities done in Ethiopia were not far more than telling the dose and frequency of administration. The most frequently mentioned barriers for medication counselling were lack of knowledge and presence of high patient load. Policy makers, stakeholders, researchers and other concerned bodies should collaborate to design interventions in order to improve the current medication counselling practices at drug retail outlets throughout the country.
- Morrow N, Hargie O, Woodman C. Consumer perceptions of and attitudes to the advice-giving role of community pharmacists. Pharm J 1993;251:25-7.
- Kansanaho H, Isonen-Sjolund N, Pietila K, Airaksinen M, Isonen T. Patient counselling profile in a Finish pharmacy. Patient EducCouns 2002;47:77-82.
- Aslanpour Z, Smith FJ. Oral counselling on dispensed medication: A survey of its extent and associated factors in a random sample of community pharmacies. Int J Pharm Pract 1997;5:57-63.
- Rees PA. Counselling and pharmacists. Pharm J 1996;257:659.
- Lam P, Krass I. Prescription-related counselling: what information do you offer? Aust Pharm 1995;14:342-7.
- Krass I. A comparison of clients? experiences of counselling for prescriptions and over-the-counter medications in two types of pharmacies: validation of a research instrument. J Soc Admin Pharm 1996;13:206-14.
- Food, Medicine and Healthcare Administration and Control Authority of Ethiopia. Manual for medicines good dispensing practice. 2nd edition, May 2012.
- Schommer JC, Sullivan DL, Wiederholt JB. Comparison of methods used for estimating pharmacist counselling behaviours. J Pharm Technol 1994;10:261-8.
- Public Law 101-508. Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990. 1992. Available at: http://www.indianamedicaid.com/ihcp/PharmacyServices/pdf/what/omnibus.pdf
- Pharmaceutical Society of Australia. Guidelines for pharmacists on providing medicines information to patients. In: Australian Pharmaceutical Formulary and Handbook. 20th edition, Canberra: PSA. 2006;pp: 365-8.
- USP medication counselling behaviour guidelines. 1992. Available at: http://www.ipsf.org
- ASHP guidelines on pharmacist-conducted patient counselling. Am J Hosp Pharm 1993;50:505-6.
- American Society of Consultant Pharmacists. Guidelines for pharmacist counselling of geriatric patients. 1998. Available at: http://www.ascp.com
- Rantucci MJ. Pharmacists Talking With Patients: A Guide to Patient Counselling. 2nd edition. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2007.
- Chandra A, Malcolm N, Fetters M. Practising health promotion through pharmacy counseling activities. Health PromotPract 2003;4:64-71.
- Wu JYF, Leung WYS, Chang S, Lee B, Zee B. Effectiveness of telephone counselling by a pharmacist in reducing mortality in patients receiving polypharmacy: Randomised controlled trial. BMJ 2006;333:522-5.
- Liu MY, Jenning JP, Samuelson WM, Sullivan CA, Veltri JC. Asthma patients? satisfaction with the frequency and content of pharmacist counselling. J Am Pharm Assoc 1999;39:493-8.
- Ebid AH, Abdel-Wahab E. Bronchial asthma and COPD: Impact of pharmaceutical care on outcomes and quality of life in Egyptian patients. Bulletin of Pharmaceutical Sciences 2006;29:167-85.
- Popovich NG. Ambulatory patient care. In:Geanaro AR (ed.), Remington: the science and practice of pharmacy, Mack Publishing Company Pennsylvania. 19th edition, 1995;2:1965-71.
- WHO. Promoting rational use of medicines core components WHO policy perspective on medicines. Geneva; Sep 2002;1-6.
- Johanna D, Pointier P,Mokhiber LH. Important information regarding medication error preventing and patient and patient counselling practice alerts and guidelines, 2004.
- Drug Administration and control Authority of Ethiopia (DACA).Promoting rational use of drugs; drug information bulletin.2004;2:1-10.
- Zewdie D, Jorge Y,Gebre Mariam T. A preliminary assessment of outpatient counselling in four referral Hospitals of Addis Ababa. Ethiop Pharm J 1999;17;44-50.
- Abula T, Worku A, Thomas K. Assessment of the dispensing practices of drug retail outlets in selected towns, North West Ethiopia. Ethiop Med J 2006;44:145-50.
- Wabe NT, Raju NJ,Angamo MT. Knowledge, attitude and practice of patient medication counselling among drug dispensers in North West Ethiopia. JAPS 2011;01:85-90.
- Berry DC, Michas IC, Gillie T, Forster M. What do patients want to know about their medicines, and what do doctors want to tell them?: A comparative study. Psychology & Health 1997;12:4,467-80.
- Regensberg LD, Tanchel M. Are we telling elderly patients enough about their medication? S AfrMed J 1988;74:229-30.
- Koo M, Krass I, Aslani P. Consumer use of consumermedicine information. J Pharm Pract Res2005;35:94-8.
- Berhane A, Getahun A, Azanaw A, Hamza S. What patients want to know about their medication? A survey of Inpatients and Outpatients at Gondar University Hospital. Int J Pharm Sci Res 2013;4;434-9.
- Dickinson D, Raynor DK, Kennedy JG, Bonaccorso S. What information do patients need about medicines? British Medical Journal 2003;327:861-4.
- Sinaa A, Norah OA. Counselling practices in community pharmacies in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia: a cross-sectional study. BMC Health Services Research 2015;15:557-66.
- Azhar H,Mohamed I. Medication counselling and dispensing practices at community pharmacies: a comparative cross sectional study from Pakistan. Int J Clin Pharm 2011;33:859-67.
- Hanni P, Parisa A, Ines K. A review of counselling practices on prescription medicines in community pharmacies. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy 2009;5:197-210.
- Dickinson D, Raynor DK. Ask the patientsthey may want to know more than you think. BMJ 2003;327:861.
- Nair K, Dolovich L, Cassels A, McCormack J, LevineM. What patientswant toknowabout their medications:Focus group study of patient and clinician perspectives? Can Fam Physician 2002;48:104-10.
- Zieger DK, Mosier M, Buenaver BS, Okuyemi K. How much information about adverse effects of medication do patients want from physicians? Arch Intern Med 2001;161:706-13.
- Berry DC, Bradlow A, Bersellini E. Perceptions of the risks and benefits of medicines in patients with rheumatoid arthritis and other painful musculoskeletal conditions. Rheumatology 2004;43:901-5.
- Schommer JC, Wiederholt JB. Pharmacists? views ofpatient counselling. Am Pharm 1994:46-53.
- Wale T, Fola T, Bola A, Abdulganiyu G. Barriers to medication counselling in community pharmacies in Lagos southwest Nigeria.
- Tully MP, Gyllenstrand-Beckman A, BernstenCB. Factors predicting poor counselling about prescription medicines in Swedish community pharmacies. Patient Education and Counselling 2010;18;3-6.
- Adepu R, Nagavi BG. Attitude and behaviours of practicing community pharmacists towards patient counselling. Indian J Pharm Sci 2009;71:285-9.
- Svarstad BL, Bultman DC, Mount JK. Patient counselling provided in community pharmacies: Effect of state regulation, pharmacist age, and business. Journal of American Pharmacy Association 2004;44:22-9.
- Azhar S. The role of pharmacists in developing countries: the current scenario in Pakistan. Hum Resour Health 2009;7:54.
- Rabbani F. Behind the counter: pharmacies and dispensing patterns of pharmacy attendants in Karachi. J Pakistan Med Assoc. 2001;51:149-54.
- Ramesh A, Nagavi B,Mahendra K. patient counseling; practicing community pharmacists? perceptions from two south Indian states. Indian J Pharm Sci2004;66:44-8.
- Adepu R,Nagavi BG. Attitudes and behaviours of practicing community pharmacists towards patient counselling. Indian J Pharm Sci 2009;71:285-9.
- Gokcekus L, Toklu HZ, Demirdamar R, Gumusel B. Dispensing practice in the community pharmacies in the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus. Int J Clin Pharm 2012;34:312-24.